Watched: 05/26/2025
Format: Max
Viewing: First
Director: Matt Wolf
Watching Pee-Wee as Himself (2025) is a strange journey. There was a lot I didn't know up until when he joined The Groundlings, and then there was what I did know - including the two arrests. But in the end, the film kind of unravels a bit in a way that seems almost inevitable - surely director Matt Wolf laying the trail to let us know this is coming.
Beyond that, the doc faces the same problem that I found with the recent Steve Martin documentary. It's a lengthy film, it criss-crosses the years and draws connections, but the subject is so practiced at maintaining their inner-selves, and their privacy, that even at the end, you feel like you barely saw anything even after 3 hours.
Jumbles of photos from a childhood are interesting, but don't tell a story. Talking heads commenting on what they're already framing are useful, and provide color, but it feels very carefully managed - we're told it's carefully managed. We keep seeing the collections, but there's no discussion of what's in there, or why (and as a collector, I know there's a story behind everything). We see his parents, but they won't ever come out and discuss them beyond "his dad was macho and may not have liked Paul's lifestyle". His mother is a non-entity.
Both Paul Reubens and Steve Martin, who agreed to let themselves be known via documentary, still want to control, and so we get a look through a very narrow lens, which is better than nothing, but it feels more questions are raised than are satisfied. If you want to spend time with how Pee-Wee came to be - then we've got a great film for you. If you want to know Paul Reubens, that may not really happen.