Watched: 03/08/2026
Format: YouTube link here
Viewing: First
Director: Robert Wise
Interesting premise for a film, and, in my opinion - very well executed.
In 1864, Joseph Cotten is a captured Confederate infantry officer. Cornel Wilde plays a wounded Union officer who won't be sent back to the front line, but which the Army of the Republic will send to the frontier. Lincoln is offering Confederate prisoners an opportunity to join the Union Army and go protect the mail routes and interests on the US, freeing up the regular soldiers to fight in the war. And, so Wilde recruits Cotten and his regiment, which Cotten does so he won't die or disease in a frigid Illinois prison.
Arrived, we find the Fort is headed by a semi-crippled officer, Major Henry Kenniston (Jeff Chandler). Kenniston's brother was killed during a major battle, widowing Linda Darnell. Darnell plays a Californian/ Mexican (which she did in a couple of movies, it seems) and is the object of desire for Wilde, Chandler and maybe a bit for Cotten. She is, after all, Linda Darnell.
Chandler's officer has a bit of a Kurtz/ Ahab vibe. His leg is not what it was, and he has a mad-on for anyone who isn't a union soldier. Also, he is maybe lightly holding his sister-in-law at the Fort despite her wish to get to California. The "I hate everyone" bit is a bad fit for the arriving ex-Confederates. And the Natives outside the Fort, with whom he is developing beef.
This is a weirdly really good movie, and I'm shocked it's not found its way into the canon. It doesn't often look like a John Ford movie, perhaps a bit more economical. But it deals with the problem of reconciliation not just after but *during* a war. Is anyone who they were when they left? Is home what it was? What comes after? And do you hang onto that hate? Do you have responsibilities bigger than the oaths of war?
Cotten's Colonel character is a man of convictions, and those are often in conflict. He urges his men to join the Union to get them out of the hell of prison camp life and give them a chance to get back to the fighting. But he also can't leave anyone to ust die, and so is pushed and pulled as he finds himself looking back toward Texas but knowing he must safely escort some wagon trains. But he also harbors plenty of anger toward the Union for what he knows Sherman has done to his home (some Civil War 101 knowledge will be helpful watching the movie).
The movie doesn't look away from the violence inflicted by and inflicted upon our outpost. I genuinely was shocked at the violence in an attack on the Fort by an army of Kiowas. Wise captures the attack by an overwhelming force in devastating terms - revenge for some of Kenniston's actions. Again, it's *on theme* as we look at what war is and the devastation it brings.
I don't know if reviewers in 1950 saw the film in political terms it would be viewed with today. It's another western with the cavalry, a beautiful woman in the wilderness, and angry natives. But how those pieces are used has thematic resonance - and that's where I felt Wise's influence. He can make a fairly standard-looking picture, and it will still have plenty of material to chew on - there's a sense of what we'd now call "social justice" baked into the questions the stories raise.
What it does not do - and very few movies from this era are willing to touch - is raise the actual stakes of the Civil War. The roots of the war are often vaguely hinted at, slavery rarely discussed as a cause, and it's much more along the "a gentleman's disagreement about State's Rights" that your worst cousin will still insist upon bringing up at Thanksgiving.
The movie seems to begin with the existential threat of the natives being the reason the force is needed. But as we move along, that simple picture is distorted - but managed in a way to satisfy the Hayes Code, while still making it clear, our guys aren't necessarily heroes out there.
Darnell's character's heritage is coded as "exotic white" and I suppose it's the casting of Darnell in the role that kept it from facing the rules about miscengination.
I did look it up, and, indeed a few thousand Confederate prisoners of war did serve in the Union army on the frontier (we all learn new things every day).
I'm not sure the movie is *great*, but I'd sure watch it again. Pleasantly surprised by this one.
No comments:
Post a Comment