Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Noirvember Watch: Mildred Pierce (1945)



Watched:  11/16/2026
Format:  Criterion Disc
Viewing:  Unknown
Director:  Michael Curtiz


They showed us Mildred Pierce (1945) when I was in film school.  I remember the auditorium, but not which class and the context within the class.  What I do remember is loving the movie and, after years of "no wire hangers" jokes as my only point of reference, was bowled over by Joan Crawford.  Yes, in that way, too.

I didn't yet know director Michael Curtiz - who would swiftly become a name that equaled "worth a watch" in my book.  I've pondered doing a run of just Curtiz films here, but it'd be a lot.  Man was prolific.  I also didn't clock Zachary Scott - a product of Austin and University of Texas - who my instructors failed to contextualize even with the Zach Scott theatre sitting on Lamar and Barton Springs (today known just as "The Zach").  

I probably hadn't read any James M. Cain yet when I saw the movie (and I need to get back to reading more), but he's the author of The Postman Always Rings Twice, a great book and a better movie.  I have not read Double Indemnity, but think maybe I will after Christmas.

The movie of Mildred Pierce is, foremost, a soapy melodrama, secondarily it's a mid-century woman's picture, and third it's film noir, which it starts as, diverts from for a very long time, and then comes back to the crime with the gas pedal all the way down.

The cultural hop from 1941 when the book was published to a WWII-era film feels like a quantum jump.  The consideration of a woman working fluctuated wildly during the 20th century and the story feels pre-war in a lot of ways, including men leeching off a woman, which would have maybe been handled differently a decade later. 

It's a movie about the limits of unconditional love, unchecked narcissism, lay-abouts being a problem.  Sticking with that Depression-era argument, it's a movie that thinks about money, who has it, who wants it, how we get it, and how it makes the world go-round, centered in class differences, family money, and what it means to be part of the elite. 

Crawford is electric.  She plays victim in a weird cycle of abuse with her own daughter, while she's a bulldog for that same daughter, someone who feels her birth into such common circumstances is a mistake and her family beneath her rightful place.  Crawford's Mildred Pierce built an empire for that girl and done nothing but enable a monster.  It's a heck of a role, perfect for Crawford's own iron will and vulnerability - and her willingness to play imperfect leads.

As a noir, it absolutely has a femme fatale; the daughter, played brilliantly by Ann Blyth, who passed this summer at 98. The movie isn't subtle about how awful Veda is from the moment where Veda is more interested in her new dress than the fact her father just left.  And it's a bit stunning to see a Code-era movie where a husband, in the form of Zach Scott, is making time with his wife's daughter.  

Anyway, it's an all-around tragedy.  Good stuff.

Also, it has Eve Arden in her role that she'd play for the next fifteen years:  Eve Arden.  That's a feature, not a bug.

One of the weapons in the arsenal is Cinematographer, Ernest Haller, who manages to capture the environs as well as the tortured face and eyes of Crawford, now pushing forty and considered to be on her way out before landing this role.  She's beautiful, but the ingenue is replaced by the woman she'd be in film for the next decade or so.  Haller also perfectly lights and frames the places from common tract homes to the sprawling Beragon mansion and labyrinthine beach house.    

Haller also lensed Gone with the Wind, Rebel Without a Cause and more movies with legendary Hollywood imagery, and this is just one more feather in his cap. 

Hollywood was clearly going all in on this one with Max Steiner as the composer, and a murderer's row of writers onboard, including William Faulkner.  

I dig the movie as a soapy melodrama with a hissable villain, as a woman's picture about the possibilities for a woman going out on their own, and as a noir about a woman drowning under the people she's tried to care for and love.  I am less in love with the hint that she would have been happier with her first husband who was openly cheating on her, and in 2026 find it hilarious that a movie would admit that maybe you're making shitty kids by spoiling them rotten - you can't buy love with a PS5.  Also, Crawford in softly lit close-ups looking constantly mildly horrified.


second best looking product of Lawton, Oklahoma



Crawford would go on to win the Oscar for her role, receiving the statue while in full make-up but in bed.  No, she was not actually ill, just pretty sure she wasn't going to win, and then...  what do you know?  The staging meant Crawford actually did have one of the most famous Oscar moments of all time.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Keep it friendly. Comment moderation is now on (which means your comment will not automagically appear). Your comment will be reviewed and published if it is reasonable. if it is not published, please do some self-reflection.