Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Noirvember Watch: The Postman Always Rings Twice (1946)




Watched:  11/17/2026
Format:  BluRay
Viewing:  No idea
Director:  Tay Garnett


After watching Mildred Pierce, I was in the mood for more James M. Cain crazy melodrama, and so reached for one that Jamie, against all odds living in this house, had never seen.  

This lack of Postman surprised me.  I've seen this movie *a lot* and I do not do so under the auspices of wanting alone time with Lana Turner.  It was I who brought Jamie Imitation of Life.  

Anyway, with that, we selected The Postman Always Rings Twice (1946) for a screening.  And, yes, I need to watch the 1981 version soon.  I've heard it's something else.

Jamie's review was "two dumb psychos" and "but I liked it".  And she is not wrong.  At some point Jamie stated "this doesn't seem like a good idea?" to one of the many bad things that happens in this movie, and I assured her "this is not a movie about two criminal masterminds".  Maybe that's some joy of the movie - watching these two horny dopes just bumblefuck their way into a very noir ending.  

As we've been doing this month, we're rewatching some noir classics.   I did watch part of this movie last year with Doug, but it was more just on as we were between activities of the holiday, so it's good to sit and watch and give the movie its due.  

It's been... three decades probably since I read the book, but my memory is that the movie hews pretty close to book, and it certainly fits the spirit of of what Cain wrote.  It's kind of a nasty story about flawed people who collide who shouldn't.  

John Garfield plays Frank - not exactly a drifter, but a guy who can't commit to anything in life, and winds up in a gas station cafe on the road to Los Angeles.  He's hired by the owner, Nick, a jovial older guy who likes Frank immediately.  But then we meet Nick's wife, Cora, an absolute bombshell in the form of Lana Turner wearing almost all white.

Frank and Cora fall hard, though she tries to resist his advances, knowing Nick is the secure sure bet and Frank is a vagabond.  And they try to leave, but can't.  And they try to maybe remove Nick from the picture, and that doesn't work - this isn't Double Indemnity, really.   But when Nick decides to pull up stakes and take Cora to Canada somewhere, Cora - who wants to stay near LA and be someone - rightfully flips out.  She is *not* going to move to small town Canada and care for Nick's invalid sister.  

I'm a John Garfield fan, and this movie is one of many reasons why.  Dude knew how to play an emotion that keeps bubbling up like a volcano ready to blow.  In this case, it's a few volcanoes, starting with lust, then love, then helpless fear.  He's a man trapped by his own inadequacies, and while Cora keeps insisting he's smart... we know that's flattery.

I am unclear when Lana Turner became *Lana Turner*, but I assume it was well before Postman.  They even taught us the legend of Lana Turner's discovery in film school - that stuff is Hollywood history, kids.  By this film, she's been perfected for the screen, distinctly Lana Turner while reflecting back Harlow and Landis and pre-saging Monroe.  





I'm a fan of Turner.  Like those others I named, Turner wasn't just gorgeous, she could act, and she's really damn good in this part.  I totally get why they tapped Jessica Lange for the 1981 remake - she's also an actor underestimated as both character and in real life, someone with unplumbed depths men ignore in their ragged desire.  

Indeed, a couple of lines really stand out.

One is how men have been hassling her since she was fourteen - and given how Turner was discovered and then put on screen at sixteen, sure feels relevant.

The other is that Frank has been trying to turn her into a tramp since he met her.  And she sure doesn't mean a "hobo".  

Anyway, #justice4cora/lana

I don't really know how or why Cain leaned so hard into complex female leads, but he sure did.  And I'm always glad for how this movie works.  I am, however, always surprised Lana Turner is only really known in classic film circles.  It's not like she didn't have her fair share of misery for the sorts of melodramas that lock in a pop culture legend.

The movie also features a very early appearance by Audrey Totter, and, man, is she ever Audrey Totter right out of the gate.

Trouble with a capital Totter


But it also has noir staple Leon Ames and Hume Cronyn as the DA and a defense attorney, respectively.  Both rock solid.  

Fun fact!  The guy who plays Kennedy, the heavy who tries to shake down Frank and Cora is Alan Reed, the OG voice of Fred Flinstone!

Anyway, if you've never seen it - give it a spin.  It's way weirder and darker than you're thinking.







No comments:

Post a Comment

Keep it friendly. Comment moderation is now on (which means your comment will not automagically appear). Your comment will be reviewed and published if it is reasonable. if it is not published, please do some self-reflection.